Should a half Jewish man be discouraged from marrying a Jewess?Did Kozbi deserve to die?
How did the hit man miss?
Why is dry soil hydrophobic? Bad gardener paradox
How to check the quality of an audio sample?
What would be the ideal melee weapon made of "Phase Metal"?
Robbers: The Hidden OEIS Substring
Is Arc Length always irrational between two rational points?
Who Can Help Retag This?
Why are Hobbits so fond of mushrooms?
How can an advanced civilization forget how to manufacture its technology?
Bronze Age Underwater Civilization
Was adding milk to tea started to reduce employee tea break time?
Where is the USB2 OTG port on the RPi 4 Model B located?
PIC12F675 GP4 doesn't work
How do I determine whether a permit is required for a new gas line?
Is Trump personally blocking people on Twitter?
What is this welding tool I found in my attic?
QGIS Welcome page: What is 'pin to list' for?
How do I take a fraction to a negative power?
Can I call 112 to check a police officer's identity in the Czech Republic?
Why did the Japanese attack the Aleutians at the same time as Midway?
Science writing - exact, precise, or accurate
Extract an attribute value from XML
Would letting a multiclass character rebuild their character to be single-classed be game-breaking?
Why does resistance reduce when a conductive fabric is stretched?
Should a half Jewish man be discouraged from marrying a Jewess?
Did Kozbi deserve to die?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
Is there any source in encouraging a man who identifies as Jewish but isn't so Halachically, to marry a Jewish woman and raise a Jewish family?
For instance, a patrilineal Jew although he isn't Jewish, if he is a cultural Jew and wishes to continue his Jewish family's legacy should he still be disuaded from marrying a non-religious Jewish woman? Is there a religious duty or source to have Jewish children?
Note:
I ask because I am aware that a convert who is patrilineally Jewish has a slightly different status to a regular convert as he has the status of 'זרע ישראל' and is considered “מקרב אחיך" according the Aruch haShulchan in Choshen Mishpat 7:1.
am-yisrael-jewish-nation matrilineal-descent jewishness
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
add a comment |
Is there any source in encouraging a man who identifies as Jewish but isn't so Halachically, to marry a Jewish woman and raise a Jewish family?
For instance, a patrilineal Jew although he isn't Jewish, if he is a cultural Jew and wishes to continue his Jewish family's legacy should he still be disuaded from marrying a non-religious Jewish woman? Is there a religious duty or source to have Jewish children?
Note:
I ask because I am aware that a convert who is patrilineally Jewish has a slightly different status to a regular convert as he has the status of 'זרע ישראל' and is considered “מקרב אחיך" according the Aruch haShulchan in Choshen Mishpat 7:1.
am-yisrael-jewish-nation matrilineal-descent jewishness
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
add a comment |
Is there any source in encouraging a man who identifies as Jewish but isn't so Halachically, to marry a Jewish woman and raise a Jewish family?
For instance, a patrilineal Jew although he isn't Jewish, if he is a cultural Jew and wishes to continue his Jewish family's legacy should he still be disuaded from marrying a non-religious Jewish woman? Is there a religious duty or source to have Jewish children?
Note:
I ask because I am aware that a convert who is patrilineally Jewish has a slightly different status to a regular convert as he has the status of 'זרע ישראל' and is considered “מקרב אחיך" according the Aruch haShulchan in Choshen Mishpat 7:1.
am-yisrael-jewish-nation matrilineal-descent jewishness
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
Is there any source in encouraging a man who identifies as Jewish but isn't so Halachically, to marry a Jewish woman and raise a Jewish family?
For instance, a patrilineal Jew although he isn't Jewish, if he is a cultural Jew and wishes to continue his Jewish family's legacy should he still be disuaded from marrying a non-religious Jewish woman? Is there a religious duty or source to have Jewish children?
Note:
I ask because I am aware that a convert who is patrilineally Jewish has a slightly different status to a regular convert as he has the status of 'זרע ישראל' and is considered “מקרב אחיך" according the Aruch haShulchan in Choshen Mishpat 7:1.
am-yisrael-jewish-nation matrilineal-descent jewishness
am-yisrael-jewish-nation matrilineal-descent jewishness
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
edited Apr 3 at 0:56
El Shteiger
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
asked Mar 26 at 2:08
El ShteigerEl Shteiger
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
1,3329 silver badges20 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
add a comment |
Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
add a comment |
The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
add a comment |
The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
edited Mar 27 at 3:41
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
answered Mar 26 at 2:18
ezraezra
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
12k2 gold badges14 silver badges59 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
add a comment |
Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
add a comment |
Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
answered Mar 26 at 12:07
chortkov2chortkov2
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
2,7183 silver badges33 bronze badges
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
add a comment |
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
3
3
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
Which prohibition is that for him?
– Double AA♦
Mar 26 at 12:09
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
@DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues)
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 13:07
1
1
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
@Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388
– Y e z
Mar 26 at 13:55
1
1
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
@Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'.
– Orangesandlemons
Mar 26 at 14:24
add a comment |
